October 10 is World Mental Health Day. Many of the churches around our Diocese will be marking the day at special services on the Sunday before, 9 October, and resources for churches to use are available online at www.mentality.org.uk.
The DOOR spoke to Hilary Caldicott, a Christian who has suffered with mental health problems for many years, about her experiences of the Church at this time.
‘Being a member of a church now is helping me stay well,’ says Hilary Caldicott. But this relationship of support and care from a church community hasn’t always been there. There were years when Hilary felt she couldn’t go near a church. And though she doesn’t blame the church for that, she admits many churches still have a long way to go in being supportive of people with mental health problems.
Hilary, now 51, was brought up in a non-conformist family and attended church regularly as a child and teenager. But it was around the age of 14 that her health problems started.
‘I was in and out of mental hospitals for years. Looking back, it was a desperate time really but I have now been away from hospital and hospital admissions for over 15 years.’
Despite her problems, she never lost her faith, though she kept away from church and spent years outside any church community.
‘In my despair, I couldn’t follow the right path, felt that I didn’t have anything to offer a church.
‘I don’t think I have ever lost my faith, though during the worst times I felt that God could not possibly be interested in me, that I couldn’t have a personal relationship with God, but I didn’t lose my faith.’
Sometimes, she would go along to churches and sit in the back to listen. But she felt excluded from being a member of the community.
‘I feel my mental health problems have been a spiritual journey, my faith and my problems were intimately connected for me.’
But it was a very long time before she felt she could go back to church.
‘It was only when I got better that I began exploring that side of myself more, that I felt able to go to a church and ask questions. I went back to church because of changes in my personal life, not the other way round.’
It was through other people in the mental health community that she started going to church, and she now worships at St Mary and St John in Cowley, though she lives near Witney.
The church has a significant presence of people with mental health problems, she says, and that is important for her.
She was confirmed there three years ago, at the Easter vigil service.
‘It had been a very long journey for me. I was 48 when I was confirmed.
‘It took me a couple of years to decide on confirmation but once I had decided I felt absolutely determined on it, there was no faltering at all.
‘I hadn’t thought about confirmation before – for many years I had thought I would never be able to join a church again, even. There are still lots of things I disagree with profoundly in the Anglican church, but I feel now I can cope with them from inside, rather than outside.’
All her adult working life has been spent in the care field.
She was formerly director of Oxfordshire MIND and now works for Advance Housing, in Witney, as programme manager for their shared housing scheme which helps people with mental health problems buy their own homes.
She is also committed to using her experiences to help the church become more open to supporting people with difficulties.
‘People in churches get a bit muddled about what their responses to people with mental health problems should be as Christians – but you don’t go to church to meet a professional psychiatrist, you go as a Christian to be part of a faith community. People want to be welcomed in as part of a community, not to be asked about their medication.
‘It is very individual, the way that people want to be welcomed or supported, and it changes from person to person. Some people need to do things at their own pace and other people may have a more outgoing approach. They just need to be treated as ordinary human beings.’
She is involved in piloting a resource pack for churches to help them in supporting people, and will also present a motion to diocesan synod in November, highlighting the need for the Christian community to engage positively with the mental health needs of people within our communities. Supported by the Board for Social Responsibility’s Health and Social Care Group, the motion welcomes the new resource produced for the Archbishops’ Council called Promoting Mental Health: A Training Resource for Spiritual and Pastoral Care. This is a web resource available on www.mentality.org.uk (click on ‘publications) and includes worship material for churches to use to mark World Mental Health day.


A bunch of women who succeeded in obtaining a "two a penny degree" in between their shopping trips had me almost sectioned.They are morons.All of them.
My reply to the writer who says 'I'm a tad off balance' and made a 'sweeping statement' on mental illness, I should like to say that both myself and my daughter have been on medication for years. I know fully well that my daughter would be in a far worse position without the aid of medication and for myself that I need help with my own mental health problems. I have had to fight for years to get help for my daughter from the Services each time she relapses. However, mental health services have not been able to offer any real freedom or breakthrough in contrast to Jesus being able to deliver us from serious mental illness. We don't need 'church' or religious rhetoric, we need the anointing from the Father to break the yoke of oppression and illness. If a relapse occurs, we need further prayer. Despite all that my daughter has gone through and myself, Jesus is still my hope. Is there any other hope that is stronger than Jesus? If not, we may as well give up!!
The writer is so right in saying that only Jesus can set us free. My daughter has chronic schizophrenia and I have suffered from anxiety and agoraphobia for the past 3 years. I have finally found a church that is very supportive and are seeking the Father's presence and healing. Most churches do not handle broken people well and particularly those with mental health problems. In Iasiah the Lord says 'He will not break a broken reed'. He has such a heart for those who are so damaged. Only Jesus can totally heal and restore and 'give us beauty for ashes'.
While I understand where you are coming from in this sweeping judgment of mental health assistance, you are a tad off balance.
I, too was miraculously "delivered" from depression and didn't have a problem with it for 14 years.... but any illness, regardless of remission, can flare up.
Do you go to a medical doctor when you are physically ill? Isn't that something dealing with "flesh and blood"?
We are triune beings.... spirit, souls and bodies. Our spirit deals with things spiritual. Our bodies deal with things physical. And our souls deal with mind, will and emotions.
God created us so wonderfully that we are still ignorant of how the brain operates....
and any mental illness involves, at least in part, the brain working.
Its sad that there are so many people who love God that are harshly judged because they need a "head doctor" when some churches would treat them better if they had a physical illness.
What a sad verdict on the Church's approach to Mental Health (Making a spiritual journey to mental health - October Door). The writer commented that she didn't go to church seeking a psychiatrist. Paul writes that it is powers and principalities that we fight, not flesh and blood. Psychiatry deals with flesh and blood, which although having a palliative, band-aid effect in some cases, cannot deliver the freedom that only Jesus Christ can bring. It is so lamentable that the Church of England, along with perhaps the other big established denominations, ceased by decree to practice healing in the 4th century, when the healing power of our Lord was consigned to the bin.
Jesus came that we should have life and life abundant, not mental illness. I took anti-depressants for years, went to various 'fallen' (and in many cases equally confused and depressed) doctors, and yet received complete deliverance from the scourge of depression at the hands of a Pastor in New Zealand. I have never suffered long-term depression since, praise God!
The word 'miracle' is 'power' in Greek. We in the C of E need to rekindle our expectations that God wants to perform miracles daily - 'You don't get because you don't ask'. The miracle of healing, physical and mental, is at the core of mission. People, saved and unsaved respond in droves to miracles - the palpable work of God in the world. Without these miracles, we stumble rather and just expect psychiatry to do the job.
Defragmentation of core purpose, resulting in being sidelined, ridiculed and decline.
Leave your comments on this item
More website comments